By Fozia Z Ahmed, Shehla Arifeen & Shazia T Hussain
UK academia is widely recognised to be facing a crisis, with a shrinking academic and clinical academic workforce. While the reasons for this are undoubtedly complex, one group stands out: Muslim women remain significantly under-represented at every level, particularly in senior academic and leadership positions. Too often, this absence is explained through the same reductive narratives; that we lack ability or ambition, without critically examining the structures of power and informal back channels that shape career progression, promotion and recognition.
If we look beyond the polished language of equality, diversity and inclusion strategies, a different picture emerges. Informal systems and structures of power, often male dominated networks, continue to shape and influence who is supported, who advances, and who is quietly left behind or edged out. These systems operate most effectively when they are least visible. These processes are not inherently unethical, but when they lack transparency or accountability, they can reinforce existing inequalities and exclude those who sit outside established circles of influence.
For many Muslim women, these dynamics are often experienced at the intersection of gender, ethnicity, faith and visibility. Navigating environments in which they are simultaneously hyper-visible and invisible at the same time; invited into spaces as symbols of diversity, yet excluded from the credit, authorship and recognition that sustain academic careers and determine progression. Inclusion becomes conditional and participation becomes extractive.
Structural academic abuse of power is not characterised by a single event, but by repeated acts of exclusion.
When publicly funded institutions tolerate these dynamics, they legitimise harmful behaviours, function as enablers of unethical practices, and embolden the actors who benefit from it. Harmful practices then become a successful recipe that is reproduced time and again across different departments and institutions. Behaviours become normalised instead of challenged. Those who benefit from existing systems are not going to be the ones who change a system that serves their interests.
Abuse comes in many forms. Harm does not always announce itself through insults, raised voices, overt hostility or explicit discrimination. More often, in professional spaces, it is embedded within routine institutional practices that quietly erode opportunity, deny recognition and restrict professional advancement. We might describe these processes as structural academic abuse: the misuse of institutional and interpersonal power that systematically disadvantages individuals while preserving hierarchies.
Structural academic abuse of power is not characterised by a single event, but by repeated acts of exclusion. Often manifesting through withdrawal of professional support, exclusion from strategic collaborations, and the slow closing of doors that were never fully open to start with. Although each action may appear minor in isolation, their cumulative effect can fundamentally alter career trajectories. Over time, these practices narrow the pool of individuals recognised as thinkers, creators and scholars.
Senior academics, often men of power embedded in influential networks, frequently control access to funding, professional networks and inclusion in collaborations. Where accountability is weak, these imbalances create opportunities for exploitation. Raising concerns is professionally risky. When women do speak up, their voices are often minimised. They may find themselves marginalised, characterised as difficult, or subjected to reputational damage in the form of insinuation or gossip, which repeated often enough by those in positions of power further occludes progress, diminishes credibility and limits future opportunities.
Many Muslim women enter academia and professional spaces in the belief that hard work, loyalty and contribution will naturally lead to recognition and career progression. Yet in environments shaped by structural misogyny and power imbalances, those assumptions are often shattered, and women may find themselves labouring under a misapprehension. As Professor Mona Siddiqui described; "the link between hard work and reward is corrupted when credit and positions are unearned, and power and privilege, rather than merit, is the determinant of who is promoted and who is left behind."
When guardrails are removed and red lines are crossed, discriminatory practices can thrive. When systems become unethical and relationships become toxic, talented women leave.
When EDI strategies fail women: when inclusion enables harm
University websites often portray academia as a meritocratic space where talent flourishes and inclusion is embedded. However, for many women from racially minoritised backgrounds, the gap between institutional promise and lived experience is so wide that they fall straight through it. What is framed as opportunity often conceals systems that protect hierarchies of power and hold women back, especially those already at the margins.
One of the most troubling features of contemporary research culture is not a single act of misconduct, but a broader pattern of unethical practices that shape whose contributions are recognised and whose work becomes visible. Ghost authorship involves the deliberate omission of individuals who have made substantial intellectual contributions. However, it rarely sits alone on the menu. For main course and dessert, we have faux inclusion, extractive mentorship, inequitable access to funding and the strategic misuse of equality, diversity and inclusion initiatives.
Muslim women, particularly those outside established academic networks or without influential sponsors, are disproportionately exposed to these predatory academic practices and especially vulnerable. They may be invited into research teams because of their expertise, contributing ideas and credibility under the assumption that recognition, authorship or inclusion will follow. Yet some later find that credit is withdrawn, roles are reduced, and contributions are quietly erased once benefit has been extracted and funding is secured. Inclusion is conditional and fragile.
These experiences represent the impact of structural academic abuses of power: highly stressful, often traumatic, and capable of altering career trajectories in profoundly negative ways. They do not merely slow progression; they constrain it, often setting into motion the slow unravelling of careers that might otherwise have flourished. For many women, this is the point at which leaving academia or leadership pathways within it, becomes the only viable option.
These practices help explain why Muslim women continue to be lost from science, research and senior leadership; not because they lack talent, ambition, or commitment, but because some academic environments make meaningful participation impossible.
Muslim women often wear many hats and carry multiple intersecting identities: they are women, Muslim, and frequently from racially minoritised backgrounds. This exposes them to the multiplicative effects of bias, prejudice, exclusion and unequal treatment.
Funders of research and institutions need to stop asking why under-representation persists in academia, research and leadership. The answer is simple. When systems become unethical and relationships become toxic, talented women leave.
Where institutions receive public funding, the responsibility does not stop at the university gate. Government-backed oversight, enforceable accountability mechanisms, and meaningful consequences for unethical conduct are essential.
The loss of Muslim women from science, academia and leadership is not accidental, nor is it the result of individual failure. It is the predictable outcome when structural misogyny and toxic masculinity operate through unethical academic practices within institutions that publicly champion equality while privately tolerating harm.
Until fairness, accountability and ethical practice are embedded into everyday academic life, Muslim women will continue to face barriers to progression and promotion. Some will leave. Not because they lack talent or ambition, but because we too have hopes and aspirations for meaningful careers - and no system should expect people to work in contradiction to the values of equality, or to endure harm in the name of EDI.
Raise your voice and get connected